Rabbi Moline Speaks Out Against James Moran in The Hill

From Rabbi Jack Moline: The Hill’s Jan. 28 article about Rep. Jim Moran’s [D-Va.] visit to a restaurant was most distressing to this resident of the 8th District of Virginia. Though I am identified correctly in the article as a supporter of his opponent, Andy Rosenberg, the challenge to the congressman’s reelection is not a contest about gustatory habits or who has more Jewish friends. It is not even about his oft-cited remark concerning the Jews and their influence on Washington. I find Mr. Moran to be delightful company and as appreciative of hospitality as the size of his appetite.

When I joined five other rabbis in calling for his resignation, it was after years of frustration with his poor performance as a member of Congress. Mistakes come with being human. The measure of leadership is when that human being can take responsibility rather than offer excuses and explanations, and so learn not to repeat mistakes of the past. Mr. Moran has failed that test.

His strength is his personal relationship with people. However, his attempt to reduce the election to a popularity contest further demeans the office he has already abused. Your article, by meeting him on his terms, legitimates the distraction. Our goal in seeking to replace him is to restore the dignity of the office with a focus on issues, values and integrity.

Peculiar as it may sound, I am insulted for Mr. Moran. Public service is exhausting and relentless in its demands. To be evaluated by the color of your hair or the crumbs on your lap is gratuitous, much like assessing a columnist on her taste in clothing or ability to make a good cup of coffee. The real issue is whether anything constructive has been contributed. In both cases, the answer is no.

Alexandria, Va.

<  |  >